Disappearance of Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley still a mystery 32 years later

Stacie Madison would have became 50 years previous in June. Her good friend, Susan Smalley, would have hit that milestone closing September. However again within the early morning hours of March 20, 1988, the 2 highschool seniors disappeared with out a hint. And their households imagine that’s when their lives ended.

Stacie’s mom, Ida Madison, who’s now 75 years previous, has lengthy authorised that her daughter is long gone, however continues to carry on to wish for solutions about what took place that evening.

“For a very long time, I stored hoping she’d stroll within the door,” Ida advised Dateline. “However I’ve given up on that. It’s been 32 years. Now, I simply need closure.”

Stacie, who used to be 17 years previous on the time, and her 18-year-old good friend, Susan Smalley, had been simply a few months clear of graduating from Newman Smith Top Faculty. They’d simply completed every week of spring damage and had been made up our minds to revel in their Saturday evening of their homeland of Carrollton, a suburb of Dallas, Texas. They deliberate to consult with some pals after which have a sleepover at Susan’s area.

Ida recalled her closing day together with her daughter. It used to be March 19, 1988.

“I have in mind I had given Stacie a perm that day,” Ida stated. “She used to be hesitant about going to Susan’s that evening. I advised her if she didn’t need to move, she didn’t need to. I want I had advised her she couldn’t move. That used to be my largest mistake.”

Stacie picked up Susan in her faded yellow 1967 Ford Mustang convertible. They spent the night buying groceries at Prestonwood The town Middle and later visited pals within the close by the town of Arlington.

Round 11:30 p.m., the women stopped on the Steak and Ale eating place, the place Susan labored as a waitress and hostess. Co-workers on the eating place stated Susan used to be there simplest a short while, speaking with pals whilst Stacie waited within the automotive.

The women had a curfew of middle of the night and made it house to Susan’s area in time to name Stacie’s mother to test in. They also referred to as a chum. It’s believed they had been there simply lengthy sufficient to make the ones telephone calls sooner than venturing out once more, Ida stated. They had been by no means observed or heard from once more.

When Stacie didn’t go back house on Sunday, Ida started to fret.

“I simply stored considering she’d stroll within the door,” Ida advised Dateline. “We went out for dinner that night and the very first thing I did once I were given house used to be test to peer if she used to be house.”

However there used to be no signal of Stacie or her automotive.

“I stayed up all evening strolling the ground,” Ida stated. “Simply looking ahead to her to seem. However she by no means did.”

On Monday morning, Stacie and Susan had been reported lacking to the Carrollton Police Division.

Two days later, on Tuesday, March 22, Stacie’s Mustang used to be found out within the parking of Webb Chapel Village on Wooded area Lane in Dallas, Texas. The doorways had been locked, the convertible best used to be up and the women’ jackets were draped over a boombox within the backseat.

In keeping with Stacie’s sister, Stefanie, Wooded area Lane used to be a cruising strip that used to be a well-liked hangout spot for teenagers within the house.

Stefanie used to be simplest six years previous when her sister disappeared.

“My reminiscences are spotty, however I take into account that time being a shift in my circle of relatives’s existence,” Stefanie stated. “I’ve reminiscences of Stacie in the home. After which she used to be long gone. Then I have in mind sitting in her room, looking ahead to her to return house. However she by no means did.”

Stefanie, who spoke to Dateline at the side of her mom, Ida, added that she recalls serving to her circle of relatives go out lacking particular person fliers within the days and weeks that adopted.

A seek for the women used to be introduced via the Carrollton Police, however the households imagine it used to be too past due.

“Investigators handled them as runaways in the beginning — that that they had prolonged their spring damage and long gone all the way down to South Padre Island,” Ida stated. “However I don’t imagine Stacie would have taken off like that.”

Stacie’s circle of relatives stated her Mustang used to be by no means dusted for fingerprints or forensically searched. The following weekend, a few of Stacie’s pals took it out for a power hoping to seek out any person who had observed the auto the evening the women disappeared.

“Anything else that may have helped the case used to be lengthy long gone,” Ida stated.

Susan’s brother, Wealthy Smalley, used to be away in school when he were given the decision from his mom that his more youthful sister used to be lacking.

“I wasn’t round, however I want I were,” Wealthy stated. “I believe like they dropped the ball at the case. I believe like I can have achieved extra if I used to be there.”

Detective Jeremy Chevallier, who has simplest had the case for the previous couple of years, advised Dateline that the unique investigative crew first of all believed the women had been runaways, however later introduced a lacking individuals investigation.

The women’ highschool commencement got here and went and there used to be nonetheless no signal of both of them. Ida advised Dateline the important on the time gave her Stacie’s cap and robe and degree.

“I requested, ‘What if she comes again and desires to complete the college 12 months.’” Ida stated. “However he simply advised me, “She’s already earned this.’”

Stacie, who were operating as a receptionist at an area physician’s administrative center, had plans to wait the College of North Texas.

“She used to be candy and sort and worrying,” Ida stated, describing her daughter. “She didn’t need to harm someone’s emotions. And that became out to be her downfall.”

Ida advised Dateline she fears Stacie’s boyfriend on the time had one thing to do with the women’ disappearance. She stated Stacie were looking to finish the connection, however didn’t know the way to do it peacefully.

Previous within the day sooner than Stacie disappeared, Stacie had advised her mom that if her boyfriend known as the home in search of her, “inform him I’m out with Susan.” Ida stated the boyfriend did finally end up calling and she or he adopted her daughter’s directions.

“I feel he were given mad and went out in search of them,” she stated. “And I feel he discovered them.”

In keeping with Detective Chevallier, the boyfriend used to be wondered widely and given a polygraph take a look at, which he handed.

Detective Chevallier advised Dateline that the boyfriend used to be “regarded as an individual of pastime,” however there used to be no longer sufficient proof to price him. The boyfriend isn’t an individual of pastime right now, he added.

Susan’s brother Wealthy advised Dateline that their mom held out hope for her daughter’s go back, however hasn’t spoken about her within the closing 10 years.

“Such a lot time has long gone via with none solutions,” Wealthy stated. “It’s arduous to carry directly to any hope at this level. We simply need solutions.”

Wealthy recalls his sister as being a “strong-willed, spirited” teenager who had plans to go back and forth after commencement.

Without a credible leads and a stalled investigation, the case went chilly.

In 2009, Shawn Sutherland, who graduated from the similar highschool in 1982, made up our minds to behavior an impartial investigation and printed a e-book in regards to the case titled, “This Night time Wounds Time: The Mysterious Disappearances of Stacie Madison and Susan Smalley.”

“I felt attracted to the case,” Shawn advised Dateline. “It felt like a calling to percentage their tale. Their disappearance had a large have an effect on in this neighborhood.”

Loads of leads and guidelines poured in following the discharge of the e-book, however Detective Chevallier advised Dateline that none of them has ended in any conclusions within the case.

“However we haven’t given up,” the detective added. “We proceed to take a look at all guidelines that are available in and inspire folks to return ahead with any bit of data, regardless of how important it will appear. You by no means know what knowledge will damage this situation vast open.”

Stacie’s mom continues to push for solutions in her daughter’s disappearance.

“If you recognize anything else — anything else in any respect — please name the police,” Ida stated. “It’s time for any person to return ahead. It’s previous time.”

Stefanie stated they bring to mind the case like a puzzle.

“Everybody has a work of the puzzle, but when one particular person holds directly to their piece, the puzzle isn’t completed.”

“We’ve begged for that piece of the puzzle for a very long time,” Ida interjected. “It’s time to finish it.”

On the time in their disappearance, Stacie used to be described as being five’6” tall and weighing 160 kilos. She has blonde hair, blue eyes and her ears are double-pierced. On March 20, 1988, she used to be observed dressed in a long-sleeved white sweatshirt with a red and orange brand at the entrance, white cotton pants and white shoes.

Susan used to be described as being five’eight” tall and weighing 140 kilos. She has brown hair, inexperienced eyes and her ears are pierced 3 times each and every. On March 20, 1988, she used to be observed dressed in a white sweater and blue pants. She used to be wearing a military blue shoulder bag with camel trim.

Any individual with details about the disappearance of Stacie and Susan is instructed to name the Felony Investigation Department at 972-466-3300.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *